Gruit Day - Gruitday.com

  • Home
  • Sleeping Tips
  • Bedding Guide
  • Mattress Topper
  • Reviews
  • About
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Guide / Mattress Topper vs New Mattress. Can a Topper Replace Mattress?

Mattress Topper vs New Mattress. Can a Topper Replace Mattress?

Mattress topper or new mattress? Many people do not want to invest on a new (and expensive) mattress and wonder if a mattress topper can fix the problem.

Our quick answer is YES, a good mattress topper will help, in most cases.

If your mattress is already too old (average mattress lifespan is 7-10 years) and too bad, you definitively should buy a new mattress. But if your current mattress is still fine, a mattress topper is a great solution. It will add more comfort to your bed and renew your mattress. A topper brings many benefits to your bed that you do not to pay too much.

Your current mattress doesn’t feel soft or firm enough. It’s even a little hot to sleep at night sometimes. Or, it’s too old to sleep on. Mattresses are costly, and replacing them isn’t always a smart choice. On the other hand, people have said many good things about mattress toppers. Is it all true? Can a topper magically fix all your problems? How do you know whether you need a new mattress or mattress topper? We will give you some examples and our pieces of advice for each, and you can decide on the best solution.

Mattress Topper vs New Mattress – 5 Situations

One: This mattress feels more like a bench!

You were expecting to feel like you are on cloud nine, but then you don’t get the comfort and support at all. In the long run, a too firm mattress will cause more troubles than displeasure like permanent body aches and severe issues with your muscles. A mattress topper is a good option in this case, to make mattress softer, with the cost being a fraction of a new mattress.

mattress topper vs new mattress
A good mattress topper brings many benefits

What do you need to do? Consider your weight, your sleep position, the temperature, and the need for allergen resistance. You will find the best mattress topper in no time!

Two: The mattress is way softer than expected. I need more support.

There’s a question for you: Is your mattress only softer than your liking? Or is the mattress too soft to support your body?

If you think the mattress isn’t cradling your body and contouring your form, you can enhance the firmness level with a firm mattress topper. But if it doesn’t provide any support and you just sink into the stiff core of its, it’s wiser to think of another mattress.

Three: It feels too hot at night! How does one sleep like this?

The mattress is comfortable enough, yet it makes you sweat so much you can’t sleep peacefully. Irritating, isn’t it? You will need something with breathability. Although memory foam is known to retain heat, heat transfer technology has gained impressive improvements. Nowadays, you can easily find a cooling memory foam mattress topper, gel-infused, and overheating will no longer be a problem.

Read more: Best Cooling Mattress Toppers

Four: It is sagging with visible indentations and lumpy areas!

If your mattress has some minor issues or small sagging,… they can be fixed with a mattress topper.

However, if your mattress is too saggy, a mattress topper won’t fix. And, you will have to suffer chronic pain, difficulty falling asleep, and discomfort in your joints. Why? The topper is a supplementary layer. It can’t patch the holes up, and your problems still exist.

So, if your current mattress is too old or too saggy, you should buy a new mattress.

firm mattress topper for back pain
Bad mattress can be harmful for your back

Five: The RV mattress isn’t doing its job!

We only spend time in the RV occasionally, therefore, a topper is a smarter investment.

With that said, if you live there or the RV mattress is sagging, it’s a whole new story. We are back to situation #4, where your only option is a new mattress.

As you might have seen by now, the only situation that requires a replacement of your mattress is the fourth, a too sagging mattress. The discussion, however, doesn’t end here.

Mattress Topper or New Mattress

Here’s another look into the matter: short-term and long-term.

Temporary solutions

You can handle most of the problems with your mattress by purchasing a mattress topper at an affordable price. It can provide you with the comfort and support your body, as well as reduce muscular pain and regulate temperature. Mattress toppers have a lifespan of 3 to 5 years. After that, the magic starts fading away.

Investment in the long run

best mattress for sleep

Immediately searching for a new mattress isn’t a good choice, at least until you have figured out the actual problem. Mattress toppers are much less expensive and beneficial. But if your mattress is too bad, you need a new mattress, keeping your budget for it will be the right way to go.

Unlike toppers, the features mattresses can provide don’t come from the surface, but the structure inside: box springs, materials, paddings. Those are what give us the comfort we long for.

Another important thing to keep in mind: You get what you pay for. Whether you decide to buy a brand-new mattress or a mattress topper, don’t hesitate to spend a good load of cash on a high-quality product. Quality means comfort and durability. We don’t want to continuously replace our purchases. That’s money going to waste for real. With some reading, you will be equipped with the necessary knowledge to choose the most fitting item for your bedroom.

Filed Under: Guide, MySidebar

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Our Guides & Recent Articles

  • Bed Bugs – Tips for Treating Bed Bugs on Mattress and Topper

    Bed Bugs – Tips for Treating Bed Bugs on Mattress and Topper

  • Know These Mattress Topper Maintenance Issues Before You Buy

    Know These Mattress Topper Maintenance Issues Before You Buy

  • 10 Simple Things That Help You Sleep Better

    10 Simple Things That Help You Sleep Better

  • Waking up Tired after 8 Hours of Sleep – 8 Reasons and Solutions

    Waking up Tired after 8 Hours of Sleep – 8 Reasons and Solutions

  • How to FIX a Sagging Mattress – DIY 6 Simple Ways

    How to FIX a Sagging Mattress – DIY 6 Simple Ways

  • How to Clean Memory Foam Mattress Topper the RIGHT Way

    How to Clean Memory Foam Mattress Topper the RIGHT Way

  • Top 10 Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper Reviews + Ultimate Guide

    Top 10 Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper Reviews + Ultimate Guide

  • Best Mattress for Back Pain – Top 5 and Buying Guide

    Best Mattress for Back Pain – Top 5 and Buying Guide

Top Reviews

  • Sleep Innovations 4-Inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper

    Sleep Innovations 4-Inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper

  • Best Cooling Mattress Pads (Toppers) – Ultimate Guide & Top 6 Picks

    Best Cooling Mattress Pads (Toppers) – Ultimate Guide & Top 6 Picks

  • Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper [REVIEW]

    Pure Green 100% Natural Latex Mattress Topper [REVIEW]

  • Linenspa Mattress Topper Review – Affordable but High Quality

    Linenspa Mattress Topper Review – Affordable but High Quality

  • Extra Plush Bamboo Fitted Mattress Topper – Affordable & High Quality Topper

    Extra Plush Bamboo Fitted Mattress Topper – Affordable & High Quality Topper

Category

  • Sleep
  • Bedding Guide
  • Mattress Topper
  • Mattress
  • Reviews

DISCLAIMER

gruitday.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

About us

Welcome to GruitDay.com – the place where we share our best articles to help you drink healthy, sleep well and live happily.

Thank you for stopping by!

Copyright © 2023 · Gruit Day

  • Contact us
  • Affiliate Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy